Proper Pie Co.

A few frequently asked questions:

***Please note: to order pies please use the email address OrderProperPieCo@gmail.com or call the shop at 804.343.7437. For all other inquiries please email ProperPieCo@gmail.com***

***For pie orders, please include the following information:

Name:
Phone number:
Date of pick up:
Time of pick up:
Type(s) of pie(s):

Thanks!***


When are you open?
Wed-Sat 12-7
Sun 12-6


Do you have the same pies everyday?
Nope! Our pie menu changes frequently. In the savory category we always have a beef, a chicken, a vegetarian, and a vegan option. More often than not, we will have another type such as pork, lamb, or fish. We have Sausage Rolls and Spinach Rolls everyday, as well as a daily Pasty. Sweet pies don't change quite as often, and we have a number of 'standards', but they do change. We post our daily menu every morning around 11 here on Facebook and also on Twitter.


Can I call ahead and place an order?
Depends, if you want a larger amount of savory pies (more than say, 8 or 10) please give us enough notice (about a day) so that we can be sure to accommodate your order. For the most part though, it is first come, first served. Pies are ready to go and we have a pretty efficient system to serve you quickly! We do run out of some selections towards the end of the day, but try our hardest to keep the pies coming all day long!


If I want to make a large order of pies, how do I do that?
The best way is to email us (Orde